Publication
Green goods: are they good or bad news for the environment? evidence from a laboratory experiment on impure public goods
| Summary: | An impure public good is a commodity that combines public and private characteristics in fixed proportions. Green goods such as dolphin-friendly tuna or green electricity programmes provide increasingly popular examples of impure public goods. We design an experiment to test how the presence of impure public goods affects pro-social behaviour. We set parameters, such that from a theoretical point of view the presence of the impure public good is behaviourally irrelevant. In a baseline setting, where the impure public good provides only small contributions to the public good, we observe that on aggregate pro-social behaviour, defined as total contributions to the public good, is lower in the presence of the impure good. Some individuals do not alter their decisions, but roughly two fifths of subjects make a lower contribution to the public good in the presence of the impure public good. On the contrary, in the case where the impure public good favours the public good component at the expense of private earnings, individuals are unaffected in their behaviour. We conclude that the presence of green goods which have only a small environmental component may reduce pro-environmental behaviour. |
|---|---|
| Main Authors: | Munro, Alistair |
| Other Authors: | Valente, Marieta |
| Subject: | Green goods Impure public goods Pro-social behaviour Social norms Experimental economics |
| Year: | 2008 |
| Country: | Portugal |
| Document type: | working paper |
| Access type: | open access |
| Associated institution: | Universidade do Minho |
| Language: | English |
| Origin: | RepositóriUM - Universidade do Minho |
Similar Items
article Green goods: are they good or bad news for the environment? Evidence from a laboratory experiment on impure public goods
by: Munro, Alistair
Published: (2016)
by: Munro, Alistair
Published: (2016)
draft On the behavioural relevance of optional and mandatory impure public goods : results from a laboratory experiment
by: Engelmann, Dirk
Published: (2011)
by: Engelmann, Dirk
Published: (2011)
article When is green too rosy? Evidence from a laboratory market experiment on green goods and externalities
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
article When Is green too rosy? Evidence from a laboratory market experiment on green goods and externalities
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
article The role of social and technical excludability for the success of impure public good and common pool agreements
by: Finus, Michael
Published: (2020)
by: Finus, Michael
Published: (2020)
article On the behavioural relevance of optional and mandatory impure public goods
by: Engelmann, Dirk
Published: (2017)
by: Engelmann, Dirk
Published: (2017)
article Subjectivism and Relational Good
by: Fritzson, Fritz-Anton
Published: (2018)
by: Fritzson, Fritz-Anton
Published: (2018)
school Consumer attitudes towards green products in the fast-moving consumer goods category in Germany
by: Schramm, Lisa Sophia
Published: (2020)
by: Schramm, Lisa Sophia
Published: (2020)
article Goodness And Beauty In Plato
by: Riegel, Nicholas
Published: (2014)
by: Riegel, Nicholas
Published: (2014)
article Good living for the next generation: between subjectivity and common good from the perspective of eco-socio-economy
by: Sampaio, Carlos Alberto Cioce
Published: (2017)
by: Sampaio, Carlos Alberto Cioce
Published: (2017)
article Judging good appearance in personnel selection
by: dos Santos Paim,Altair
Published: (2018)
by: dos Santos Paim,Altair
Published: (2018)
article Good news and bad news are still news
by: Coutts, Alexander
Published: (2019)
by: Coutts, Alexander
Published: (2019)
article System dynamics for social good
by: Gonçalves,Paulo
Published: (2019)
by: Gonçalves,Paulo
Published: (2019)
article The Form of the Good in Plato’s Timaeus
by: Gkatzaras, Thanassis
Published: (2018)
by: Gkatzaras, Thanassis
Published: (2018)
article Positional Goods and Social Equality
by: Cass, Devon
Published: (2023)
by: Cass, Devon
Published: (2023)
book Criteria for good practice in supporting inclusion and activities.
by: Portelada, A
Published: (2026)
by: Portelada, A
Published: (2026)
article Marketing social good
by: French,Jeff
Published: (2017)
by: French,Jeff
Published: (2017)
article The good of the person, the common good and conscientious objection
by: Renaud, Michel
Published: (2021)
by: Renaud, Michel
Published: (2021)
article An Exploratory, Cluster Randomised Control Trial of the PAX Good Behaviour Game
by: O’Keeffe, Joanne
Published: (2021)
by: O’Keeffe, Joanne
Published: (2021)
book Guidelines for good practice in Science Communication
by: Conceição, Manuel Célio
Published: (2024)
by: Conceição, Manuel Célio
Published: (2024)
groups Does a market with green goods voluntarily internalize externalities? Evidence from a lab experiment
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018)
article Social indexing in GoodReads and Skoob digital catalogs
by: Tolare, Jessica Beatriz
Published: (2022)
by: Tolare, Jessica Beatriz
Published: (2022)
article Utopia as common good
by: Pereira, Américo
Published: (2017)
by: Pereira, Américo
Published: (2017)
book Criteria for good practice in supporting inclusion and activities
by: Portelada, Amtónio
Published: (2024)
by: Portelada, Amtónio
Published: (2024)
article Differential behaviour and innovation in the Portuguese capital goods sector
by: Romero, Fernando
Published: (1998)
by: Romero, Fernando
Published: (1998)
science In or out? Crowding effects in public goods with private gifts: evidence from crowdfunding
by: Bernard, Anna
Published: (2025)
by: Bernard, Anna
Published: (2025)
article Goods’s Syndrome: Immunodeficiency Beyond Thymectomy
by: Queirós Gomes, Joana
Published: (2023)
by: Queirós Gomes, Joana
Published: (2023)
article Economical valuation of environmental goods and services
by: Matos, Alda
Published: (2010)
by: Matos, Alda
Published: (2010)
draft Tax morale, public goods, and politics: Experimental evidence from Mozambique
by: Sandholtz, Wayne Aaron
Published: (2024)
by: Sandholtz, Wayne Aaron
Published: (2024)
category Good and bad design: some rules about the good and bad design in DST
by: Morgado, Lina
Published: (2016)
by: Morgado, Lina
Published: (2016)
book Good practices on digital education from UAb
by: Moreira, Darlinda
Published: (2022)
by: Moreira, Darlinda
Published: (2022)
article Intermediate services’ impact on capital goods production
by: Giovanini,Adilson
Published: (2020)
by: Giovanini,Adilson
Published: (2020)
article Quality differentiation of durable goods in secondary markets
by: Saito,Richard
Published: (2003)
by: Saito,Richard
Published: (2003)
article Radiation: Bad or Good
by: Caramelo, Francisco
Published: (2018)
by: Caramelo, Francisco
Published: (2018)
article Bad (good) news and delay (anticipation) of financial statements’ disclosure
by: Vivas, Anderson Brito
Published: (2020)
by: Vivas, Anderson Brito
Published: (2020)
article Roles of customer care in consumer goods retail marketing: evidence from Vietnam
by: Pham, Cuong Hung
Published: (2022)
by: Pham, Cuong Hung
Published: (2022)
article Mapping the 'good mother': Meanings and experiences in economically and socially disadvantaged contexts
by: Narciso, Isabel
Published: (2018)
by: Narciso, Isabel
Published: (2018)
article Good environmental practices in the hospitality sector: the case of the Algarve
by: Arraes Viegas, Margarida
Published: (2011)
by: Arraes Viegas, Margarida
Published: (2011)
mic Assessing the capacity of landscapes in providing public goods based on the social demand
by: Carvalho-Ribeiro, Sónia
Published: (2014)
by: Carvalho-Ribeiro, Sónia
Published: (2014)
draft A geographic game with intermediate goods
by: Pontes, José Pedro
Published: (2001)
by: Pontes, José Pedro
Published: (2001)
Similar Items
-
article Green goods: are they good or bad news for the environment? Evidence from a laboratory experiment on impure public goods
by: Munro, Alistair
Published: (2016) -
draft On the behavioural relevance of optional and mandatory impure public goods : results from a laboratory experiment
by: Engelmann, Dirk
Published: (2011) -
article When is green too rosy? Evidence from a laboratory market experiment on green goods and externalities
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018) -
article When Is green too rosy? Evidence from a laboratory market experiment on green goods and externalities
by: Fernandes, Maria Eduarda
Published: (2018) -
article The role of social and technical excludability for the success of impure public good and common pool agreements
by: Finus, Michael
Published: (2020)